The boardroom: five critics before you write a word
Most ideas fail because nobody attacked them early. The boardroom makes the attack part of the work: an advocate learns your idea, then a novelty skeptic, a significance skeptic, a feasibility hawk, a soundness auditor and a publication strategist each challenge it in turn. You answer in your own words, and the board rules on whether your answer actually addresses the objection.
- An advocate interviews you first and keeps a visible ledger of what it still does not know.
- Five critic lenses run in a fixed order, one turn at a time — not a single blast of questions.
- Your rebuttal is adjudicated: resolved, downgraded, or told plainly that it still stands.
- The round ends in a verdict whose scores cite the objections that justify them.
- Quote a message or @mention a critic to answer it directly.
- Nothing needs a reload: every step is visible, retryable and stoppable.














